Hi Emily! Our Boyfriend shorts are not stated as an oversized fit. Sizes run from small to large, and are true to size. but are more than happy to special order in any size needed, as mentioned on our FAQ! We’re sorry you do not think the colour was not as expected, although also mentioned in our FAQ that we hand dye every item, which means every piece is unique. Although the photos are a great guide to follow; the item purchased should resemble the photo chosen. but not an exact replica. Had your order turn out completely different than what was ordered, we would have remade the pair for you. Every piece we send out is inspected to make sure the resemblance and color match is there (as close as possible). We’re very sorry you feel this way; and we would love to speak more over email about how we can make this right. Thank you so much.